Stonecutter's Menu

Stonecutters Casual Dining Restaturant on the shores of Seneca Lake

The foundation of Stonecutters is built above a shallow ravine, containing the stone fragments meticulously chipped from the thousands of tons of Medina stone used to build the Belhurst Castle. Displayed in the hallway leading to the Castle are the framed blueprints used by craftsmen who constructed Belhurst in 1885. The hand cut grist wheel at the lobby entrance and the watering trough in our main lobby once stood at White Springs Manor.



Toasted Naan Caprese  
Crisp toasted naan bread topped with roasted garlic aïoli, shredded mozzarella cheese, sliced Roma tomatoes, aged balsamic glaze and torn fresh basil. $11.95

Calamari Fritti
Tender breaded calamari tentacles and rings tossed with fresh tomato relish, Kalamata olives and pepperoncini rings. Finished with a roasted garlic aïoli and shredded Asiago cheese. $13.95

Smoked Gouda Dip
Warm dip of artichokes, spinach and Nance’s smoked Gouda served with toasted naan bread. $9.95 

Cheese Board
Selection of cured meats accompanied with local cheeses, hummus, dried fruits and pickled vegetables. $12.95

Seafood & Pancetta Chowder
Creamy chowder of shrimp, crab, white fish and pancetta served in a toasted bread bowl. $11.95 

Soup Du Jour 4 oz. cup, $4.95 or 10 oz. bowl, $8.95



Steak Chop Salad
Ancho-citrus honey marinated beef tenderloin medallions over a chop salad of romaine, radicchio, corn, black beans, diced tomatoes, red onions and crunchy tortillas tossed in chipotle ranch dressing. Finished with a drizzle of sweet mango puree. $15.95 

Strawberry & Spinach Salad
Tender baby spinach topped with fresh strawberries, avocados, bacon, candied pecans, crumbled Gorgonzola and red onion. Dressed in a raspberry vinaigrette. $11.95  (Add chicken, $3.95)

Butter Bibb and romaine lettuce topped with a blend of herb roasted chicken, celery, walnuts, red onions and grapes in a creamy poppy seed dressing. Served with toasted baguette crostini. $13.95 

Crisp romaine lettuce topped with shaved Parmesan cheese, grape tomatoes, garlic-herb croutons and creamy Caesar dressing. $11.95  (Add chicken, $3.95)

Castle Garden
Mixed field greens, romaine, grape tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, grapes and carrots. $8.95  (Add chicken, $3.95)


All selections come with a breaded pickle and choice of kettle chips or balsamic dressed field greens. Substitute french fry medley or fried onion petals for $2.95. Gluten free bun available upon request. 

Stonecutter Haddock
Beer battered haddock, lettuce, tomato, red onion and Colby Jack cheese on a brioche roll. Served with cornichon tartar sauce and lemon. $14.95

Smoked pastrami with pickles, grilled onions, brown mustard and Havarti cheese on toasted pumpernickel bread. $13.95 

Veggie Burger
Vegan/gluten free black bean patty with roasted red pepper hummus, avocado, sliced cucumber, tomatoes and spinach on a brioche roll. $12.95 

Which One For You?
Choose one: Steak burger, grilled chicken breast or turkey burger. Your selection is served on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayonnaise and NYS cheddar cheese. $11.95 (Add bacon, $2.95)

Chopped Ribeye
Sliced and roasted ribeye with A1 barbecue sauce, mayonnaise, and battered onion petals on a Kaiser roll. $13.95

Hawaiian Cuban
Roasted pork loin, cappicola, grilled pineapple, provolone cheese and chive-tarragon mayonnaise on toasted ciabatta bread. $12.95 

Buffalo Chicken Ciabatta
Tender fried chicken breast with Bibb lettuce, bleu cheese dressing and Nance’s spicy buffalo cheddar cheese on toasted ciabatta bread. $12.95 

Castle-made falafel wrapped in warm naan bread with romaine lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, feta cheese and tzatziki sauce. $12.95



Coors Light  |  Michelob Ultra  |  Amstel Light  |  Stella Artois  |  Heineken  |  Labatt Blue  |  Labatt Blue Light  |  Yuengling  |  Corona (Low Gluten)  |  Guinness  |  Ithaca Apricot Wheat  |  Bud Light  |  Saranac Pale Ale  |   C.B. MacBubba Scotch Ale  |  Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter  |  Boddingtons  |  Sam Adams Boston Lager  |  Southern Tier IPA  |  Seasonal Cider and Beer Selections also available

We carry Pepsi Cola products as well as Fresh Brewed Ice Tea, Saratoga Sparkling Water and Lemonade